Your membership has expired

The payment for your account couldn't be processed or you've canceled your account with us.

Re-activate
    outside the labs

    Best Christmas Tree Scented Candles

    A convincingly aromatic candle can help your artificial tree fake it till it makes it

    When you shop through retailer links on our site, we may earn affiliate commissions. 100% of the fees we collect are used to support our nonprofit mission. Learn more.

    several pine-scented candles on marble countertop Photo: Angela Lashbrook/Consumer Reports

    If you’ve opted for an artificial Christmas tree this year, congrats—no more messy needles to clean up come January. But you might be missing one major aspect of having a real conifer in your home, and that’s the fresh evergreen aroma of pine, fir, or spruce. 

    That distinctive smell you’re craving is due to chemical compounds in conifers called terpenes, which are abundant in the trees’ resin and made of molecules that smell of pine, citrus, and, in many minds, Christmas spirit.

    More on Holiday Prep

    Fake trees don’t have resin, but fortunately, the marketplace is flush with aromatic options this time of year. From diffusers and plug-ins to room sprays and candles, many products claim to scent your space with the smell of a tree, but few actually pull it off. 

    To find the ones that most closely mimic the Christmas tree aroma, we pointed our noses toward candles, which appeared to be the most popular medium for Christmas tree scents (although many of the brands offer their scent in diffusers and room sprays, too). 

    How We Evaluated the Christmas Tree Scented Candles

    We purchased 18 scented candles and conducted a blind sniff test to weed out the candles that smelled nothing like a Christmas tree. The majority did not make the cut, including:

    Anthropologie Eirwen, Bath & Body Works Tree Farm, Bulk Apothecary Balsam Fir, Diptyque Sapin/Pine Tree, Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day Iowa Pine, Sand + Fog Winter Pine, Threshold (Target) Forest Fir, Trapp White Fir, Village Candle Christmas Tree, Williams Sonoma Through The Woods Iced Evergreen, Yankee Candle Tree Farm Festival

    Many of these smelled sweet, not green or woody, and like generically perfumed wax. Our panel likened the candles’ scents to soap, car fresheners, cheap lotion, and the lingering effects of visiting a Hollister store.

    We put the remaining candles through a more thorough sensory evaluation and comparison, considering factors such as intensity, hedonic tone (how pleasant it is), and the candle’s throw, which is its ability to fill the room with aroma.

    Members can read on to see which three candles we’re putting out alongside our artificial Christmas trees this season.

    Become a member to read the full article and get access to digital ratings.

    We investigate, research, and test so you can choose with confidence.